A RetroSearch Logo

Home - News ( United States | United Kingdom | Italy | Germany ) - Football scores

Search Query:

Showing content from https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/UsefulNotes/MisplacedNationalism below:

Website Navigation


UsefulNotes / Misplaced Nationalism

"Any time I've been to an historical building in Ireland, after five minutes you'll see a plaque on the wall, and it says 'and then the English came and ruined it'."

It's another day on the Internet. Someone mentions a nation in passing, another person mentions something about that nation and how bad it is. Everyone takes sides, a heated argument ensues, and the original topic may never be mentioned again.

What is this force that divides Message Boards, derails discussions, and causes otherwise reasonable people to turn into frothing super-patriots? That's right, it's Misplaced Nationalism, the division of the Internet along nationalnote Nationalism is the belief that everyone is (born as) a member of a "nation", a group of people who all share certain traits (citizenship, language, culture, ethnicity). Most countries are nation-states, wherein the people of one nation predominate, but not all nations are countries and some countries — like the now-defunct Austro-Hungarian Empire — are dominated by the people of two or more "nations". lines even though it supposedly transcends borders and cultures. This generally comes hand in hand with the assumption that even though YOU may not agree with everything YOUR country does, people from other countries are totally complicit in everything their country does. Don't like their leader? Insult them for it or, better yet, blame them for supporting that person (even when they didn't). Have a grudge on their country for something that happened decades or even centuries ago? Bring it up now, and blame the current generation for it! Hold a nasty prejudice against another country? Rag on them for it! If they insist you're misinformed, tell them they're lying, because you clearly know more about their country than they do.

The typical result is that everyone else in the discussion (who up to that point had been nationless Internet entities) suddenly become flag waving patriots for whatever country they happen to be from (even if they don't actually take sides) or agree with. The argument will ALWAYS rage on permanently, and continuously, FOREVER AND EVER AND EVER, as not even moderators can stop this. Not even the Silent Majority can stop this, as they are indistinguishable from the Vocal Minority.

Although it can be hard to distinguish them from the actual Single Issue Wonks, these types of arguments are often started by Trolls looking to rile everyone up. Like with most trolling, the best way to deal with it is to ignore it and hope it goes away.

When Misplaced Nationalism breaks out, it's not uncommon to see bouts of Cultural Cringe also appear from Boomerang Bigots, who are all too happy to agree with the vitriol aimed at their countrymen. Others may beg for belligerents to Stop Being Stereotypical, especially if they're acting out negative stereotypes. Expect to see plenty of No True Scotsman fallacies in these situations as well.

See also: Patriotic Fervor, Flame War, Single-Issue Wonk, Cultural Posturing, Values Dissonance and Your Normal Is Our Taboo. Contrast Cargo Cult and Cultural Cringe. Always a form of a Forever War, with no such thing as a Silent Majority.

Examples: Note: Examples are categorized according to what the "Misplaced Nationalism" is directed at.

    open/close all folders 

    Towards North American Countries 

The United States

Canada

Mexico

Costa Rica

Misc.

    Towards South American Countries 

    Towards European Countries 

    Towards Asian Countries 

    Towards Oceanic Countries 

    Towards Middle Eastern and North African Countries 

    Towards Multiple Countries in Multiple Continents / Other 

"Pass the Popcorn!"

RetroSearch is an open source project built by @garambo | Open a GitHub Issue

Search and Browse the WWW like it's 1997 | Search results from DuckDuckGo

HTML: 3.2 | Encoding: UTF-8 | Version: 0.7.4