On Mon, Feb 25, 2002 at 12:31:55PM -0800, Paul Prescod wrote:
> Yuck!
>
> String interopolation should be a *compile time* action, not an
> operator. One of the goals, in my mind, is to allow people to string
> interpolate without knowing what the locals() function does. After all,
> that function is otherwise useless for most Python programmers (and
> should probably be moved to an introspection module).
>
> Your strategy requires the naive user to learn a) the $ syntax, b) the
> magic operator syntax and c) the meaning of the locals() function. Plus
> you've thrown away the idea that interpolation works as it does in the
> shell or in Perl/Awk/Ruby etc.
>
> At that point, in my mind, we're back where we started and should just
> use %. Well have reinvented it with a few small tweaks.
>
> Plus, operator-based evaluation has some security implications that
> compile time evaluation does not. In particular, if the left-hand thing
> can be any string then you have the potential of accidentally allowing
> the user to supply a string that allows him/her to introspect your local
> variables. That can't happen if the interpolation is done at compile
> time.
But how do you internationalize your program once you use $-subs? The
great strength of %-formats, and the *printf functions that inspired
them, are that the interpretation of the format takes place at runtime.
(printf has added positional specifiers, spelled like "%1$s", to permit
reordering of items in the format, while Python has added
key-specifiers, spelled like "%(id)s", but they're about equally
powerful)
With %-subs, we can write
def gettext(s):
""" Return the localized version of s from the message catalog """
return s
def print_chance(who, chance):
print gettext("%(who)s has a %(percent).2f%% chance of surviving") % {
'who': who,
'percent': chance * 100}
print_chance("Jeff", 1./3)
I'm not interested in any proposal that turns code that's easy to
internationalize (just add calls to gettext(), commonly spelled _(),
around each string that needs translating, then fix up the places where
the programmer was too clever) into code that's impossible to
internationalize by design.
Jeff
RetroSearch is an open source project built by @garambo | Open a GitHub Issue
Search and Browse the WWW like it's 1997 | Search results from DuckDuckGo
HTML:
3.2
| Encoding:
UTF-8
| Version:
0.7.4