On 30 January 2000, Ka-Ping Yee said:
> On Sun, 30 Jan 2000, Tim Peters wrote:
> > If this goes in (I'm not deadly opposed, just more opposed than in favor),
> > I'd like to see "else" used instead of the colon (cond "?" true "else"
> > false). The question mark is reasonably mnemonic, but a colon makes no
> > sense here.
>
> I agree with that sentiment (along the lines of the philosophy that
> chose "and" over "&&"), and it seems to me that it makes the most sense
> to use words for both:
>
> a = x > 0 then x else -x
Yeah, I agree with Tim: it's a handy feature and I frequently wish I
could do simple conditional assignment without resorting to a full-blown
if/else. (I think I stumbled across "a and b or c" myself -- either
that or it was suggested by *Learning Python*, but lay dormant in my
subconscious for several months -- which means that I missed the "b must
always be true" subtlety until it bit me. Ouch. I avoid that idiom
now.)
BUT the C line-noise syntax is not appropriate. It's fine in C, and
it's eminently appropriate in Perl -- both languages designed to
minimise wear-and-tear of programmers' keyboards. But keyboards are
cheap nowadays, so perhaps we can be a bit more profligate with them.
I find Ping's proposed syntax intriguing. Personally, I've always been
partial to the
x = if a then b else c
syntax, even though I don't think I've ever used a language that
includes it. (Oh wait, the toy ALGOL-knockoff that we used in Intro to
Compilers had it, so I *have* written a parser and simplistic code
generator for a language that includes it. Perhaps that's why I like
it...)
But either of these -- ie. elevate "then" to keywordhood, with or
without "if", and no colons to be seen -- smell like they would play
havoc with Python's grammar. And they turn a statement keyword "if"
into an expression keyword. Not being at all familiar with Python's
parser, I should just shut up now, but it feels tricky.
And of course, any proposed syntax changes nowadays have to take JPython
into account.
Greg
RetroSearch is an open source project built by @garambo | Open a GitHub Issue
Search and Browse the WWW like it's 1997 | Search results from DuckDuckGo
HTML:
3.2
| Encoding:
UTF-8
| Version:
0.7.4