** home page of She-philosopher.com:
a Web-based research project for science, technology & cultural studies,
focused on âthe long 17th centuryâ (roughly 1575–1725) **
First Published: April 2004
Revised (substantive): 18 February 2025
M Y C O U N T E R - M E S S A G E T O L E A D E R S H I P â S âA M E S S A G E F R O M Y O U R U N I O Nâ (posted 2/10/2024):
On 9 February 2024, my union household received a personalized Voterâs Guide (for the 5 March 2024 Primary election) sponsored by the California Labor Federation. This âmember communication intended for the thousands of teachers, nurses, firefighters, construction workers, and other essential union workers in the San Diego & Imperial Counties Labor Councilâ included an endorsement which so alarmed me that I knew I had to push back here.
** UPDATE (posted 10/31/2024) ** With less than a week to go until the 5 November 2024 election, my household is being inundated with fliers for the Brian Maienschein campaign. One group of fliers is âPaid for by independent Voter PAC ... California Broadband & Video Association and Sempra Energy.â The other group of fliers is âpaid for by San Diego Labor Coalition.â We have also received a phone message from our union local, the sole purpose of which was to push us to vote for Brian Maienschein. Such aggressive outreach on Maienscheinâs behalf by local unions, under the aegis of the California Federation of Labor Unions, is infuriating! Once again, my political leaders are not listening, having decided that they know better than I do whatâs best for my family.
** UPDATE (posted 11/29/2024) ** We did it! According to the San Diego County Registrar of Votersâ unofficial election results (posted after the count was completed the evening of 11/27/2024), a majority of voters rejected, by a sizable margin, Brian Maienschein, who received 43.17% of the vote, losing the race for San Diego City Attorney to Heather Ferbert, who received 56.83% of the vote. It is heartening to see that, despite his powerhouse endorsements, a career politician with a history of fake representation was not again rewarded with elective office by San Diegans. This one result has renewed my faith in our political process, and I think itâs time that I turn my attention back to local/state kitchen-table issues, and see if we can get Sacramento to enact proper fence law reforms in 2025. So stay tuned, as I gear up to revisit this neglected issue that people actually care about!
N O T E : There are 5 âhoverâ boxes used on this Web page. To learn more about DHTML hover-box technology and possible display problems with it (especially if you are using Google Chrome or Opera for Web browsing and/or viewing this Web page on a mobile device), visit She-philosopher.comâs âA Note on Site Designâ page. To view all 5 of this Web pageâs hover notes in a second-window aside (where they are clustered together like end-notes), click/tap here.
I have been working on the new and improved She-philosopher.com since 2012, when I created a beta test site for the transitional website at She-philosopher.org. Back then, I thought it was important that the original she-philosopher.com remain intact throughout the development process, and that I keep my remodeling mess out of the public eye, and off-limits to external, commercial search engines. As soon as the transitional website at She-philosopher.org was more presentable, I planned to move it over to its proper .com domain, replacing the original she-philosopher.com website which launched in 2004 and has been showing its age for some time.
I did not anticipate in 2012 that the remodeling process would take 4 years â and counting! â nor did I foresee that my standard for presentable scholarship (driven by traditional print-based publication models for academic content) would end up at odds with my creative process as a Web publisher of original, postdoctoral scholarly research.
Back then, I didnât undertand how much the online medium would shape the message.
I know better now. The new capabilities of Web publication enhance the communication process more than the product, so seeking any sort of finality is a wrong-headed goal. Even scholarly content is fungible with this medium, and to try to fix it in discrete, closed communications is to defy the online order of things, and ensure that the new and improved She-philosopher.com never emerges from beta test.
Iâve thus had another change of heart. As of July 2016, I decided to launch the new and improved She-philosopher.com as is, allowing all and sundry â including external search engines â full access, so that everyone can follow the development process and preview new content as itâs posted and being tested.
For more information about whatâs going on, start with this refashioned websiteâs âThe Site Concept: Whatâs Past Is Prologueâ and âA Note on Site Designâ Web pages, and follow the links given there to some of the new content on offer. Thereâs already a lot here to explore.
Please remember while you do so that this transitional website is very much a work-in-progress. It is normal for links to be broken once in a while; for references to be missing; for our local search engine index to be updated only when I post important new content (instead of every time I correct a typo); for navigation between old & new website pages to be clumsy, especially as I reorganize some content; for pages to sometimes contain placeholder text (âLorem ipsum dolor sit amet ...â); and so on. I ask for your patience while I wend my way through this complicated redevelopment phase, with no end in sight.
^ The Unquiet Life (Vita inquieta). Emblem 322 in Pierce Tempestâs English edition of Cesare Ripaâs Iconology, entitled Iconologia: or, Moral Emblems, by Caesar Ripa (London, 1709).
Ripaâs portrayal of the hard-working Sisyphus (here symbolizing intellectual endeavors and the creative process), beset by personal demons, is glossed: âSisyphus rolling a huge Stone to the Top of a Mountain, which still falls back again. ¶ The Mountain denotes the Life of Man; the Top of it, the Quietness and Tranquillity of what we aspire to; the Stone the great Pains every one takes to arrive at it. Sisyphus signifies the Mind, which always breaths after Rest, and scarce has obtainâd it, but desires still; for some place it in Riches, some in Honours, some in Learning; this in Health, that in Reputation; so that it is found only by accident.â (P. Tempest, Iconologia, 1709, 80)
As I have noted elsewhere, anyone in the 21st century who designs, develops and/or maintains a high-quality website featuring original content (such as She-philosopher.com) is engaged in never-ending Sisyphean toil.
Unlike the labors of Hercules â which also symbolized the humanist project of the public intellectual â the labors of Sisyphus came to be associated with conflicting messages: on the one hand, pointing to the virtues of persistence and fortitude, especially when condemning oneself to immense toil, regardless of reward; and on the other hand, giving to human acts & determination the appearance of aimlessness and futility. Christian moralizing in such 17th-century books of hieroglyphics as the wildly popular Emblemes (1635), by Francis Quarles (1592â1644), associated the metaphor âThus I roll Sisyphean Stonesâ with worldly vanity, in keeping with religious teaching that âhowever highly we may esteem human arts and sciences in their proper place, it will ever be true that âthe wisdom of this world is foolishness with Godââ (Preface to 1839 edn. of Emblemes, ed. by the Rev. Augustus Toplady and the Rev. John Ryland).
Quarlesâs religious refashioning of Sisyphean struggle occurs in Emblem 15 of Book 3, which takes as its opening text Psalm 31, verse 10 (âMy life is spent with grief, and my years with sighingâ). In a peculiar conceit, clearly inspired by evolving New World identities, Quarles compares Sisyphean labors (of the free will) unfavorably with slave labor (which he presents as the more satisfying spiritual experience!): âThe branded Slave, that tugs the weary Oare, / Obtaines the Sabbath of a welcome Shore; / His ransomâd stripes are healâd; His native soile / Sweetens the memâry of his forreigne toyle: / But ah! my sorrowes are not halfe so blest; / My labour finds no point; my paines, no rest: / I barter sighs for teares; and teares for Grones, / Still vainly rolling Sysiphæan stones.â (F. Quarles, Emblemes, 1635 edn., 182) Of note, the hieroglyphic for this emblem does not depict Sisyphus at work, but instead shows a melancholic Christian, loudly lamenting (âAh meeâ) his freedom and sinful existence (âformed of earth, conceived in sinne, borne to punishmentâ), as he seeks purpose & meaning in âthe miserable ingresse of mans condition.â (F. Quarles, 183)
Such Christian repurposing of the deified abstractions and symbolic figures of antiquity appealed to ordinary folk on both sides of the Atlantic: âThe Emblems of Alciatus [as developed by Cesare Ripa] have been in as much Reputation among the more learned, as those of Quarles among the Vulgar.â (Ephraim Chambers, Cyclopaedia, 2 vols., 1728, s.v. Emblem, 1.297)
Quarlesâs book of Emblemes popularized for Protestant England and Anglo-America the Catholic baroque emblems of Pia Desideria (1624), by Herman Hugo, and Typus Mundi (1627), which was âcompiled by nine clever schoolboys at the Antwerp Jesuit college under the direction of their master.â Quarlesâs âoccasional alterations to individual plates are of no major doctrinal or sectarian significance,â and the English engravings by William Marshall et al., while competently copied, âfall short of the artistry of the Antwerp originals.â But Quarlesâs English âpoems are largely independent and new. They exploit the mimetic quality of the pictures and transform them into allegories of spiritual truth,â making Quarlesâs Emblemes âacceptable to moderate Catholics and protestants because [his book of visible poetry] promoted the general tenets of the Christian life, not controversial doctrines.â As such, Quarlesâs Emblemes âproved a cultural achievement and a durable success. It brought to protestant England, suitably adapted, the spiritual and emotional qualities of the Catholic meditation on pictures. It survived as a work of edification when the emblem tradition itself had declined and it played an important role in the Victorian emblematic revival. It has been found especially rewarding in recent studies of the interaction of word and image. Nearly all of Quarlesâs works stand in an interesting relationship to public affairs and serve to enrich the picture of Stuart England.â (Karl Josef Höltgen, ODNB entry for Francis Quarles, n. pag.)
Click/tap here to view a large digital fascimile (594KB file) of the hieroglyphic for Emblem 15 in Book 3 of Quarlesâs Emblemes (1635).
As always, several research projects Iâm trying to finish up have expanded well beyond their original scope, and are introducing further delays. To those of you waiting patiently for all the new content relating to claims by Julian Jaynes in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind (1st edn., 1976)
3. Dating the development of consciousness to around the end of the second millennium B.C. in Greece and Mesopotamia. The transition occurred at different times in other parts of the world.
(from the Myths vs. Facts About Julian Jaynesâs Theory page at the Julian Jaynes Society website)
itâs still coming, I promise. I shall be adding 16 new digital editions to the She-philosopher.com library â writings by Ovid, Francis Bacon, and Robert Hooke, along with published articles by other 17th-century English and Italian naturalists â as part of this project. Thatâs a lot of primary source material to organize and prepare, so itâs going to take me longer than I initially planned to get everything done.
I have also decided to move a lot of my research relating to the history of medicine â such as a new illustrated introductory essay on the âWoman-Physician,â Mary Trye (fl. 1662â75) (created 4/14/2016) and the companion introductory essay on her antagonist, the polymath physician Henry Stubbe (1632â1676) (also created 4/14/2016) â to a different website. And this has introduced still more delays.
But ultimately, the main reason redevelopment takes so long is because the research activity itself â richly layered with countless detours and distractions â can not be hurried along. I was recently reminded of this when I added a brief note about 17th-century druggists to an essay at a different website. There, my desire for scholarly precision too often ends up delaying the publication of time-sensitive material, preventing me from taking full advantage of yet another kairic moment. At the time, I was in a hurry to identify which
Bartholin complains of the too great number of Apothecaries in Denmark; tho’ there were but three in Copenhagen, and four in all the Kingdom beside: What would he have said of London, where there are upwards of 1300?
(Ephraim Chambers, Cyclopaedia, 2 vols., 1728, s.v. Apothecary, 1.119)
As Wikipedia summarizes, âThree generations of the Bartholin family made significant contributions to anatomical science and medicine in the 17th and 18th centuriesâ: Thomas Bartholin (1616â1680); his father, Caspar Bartholin the Elder (1585â1629); his brother, Rasmus Bartholin (1625â1698); and his son, Caspar Bartholin the Younger (1655â1738). Between them, the four Bartholins published over 20 works, all in Baroque Latin, totaling thousands of pages. It could easily take me several months to locate copies of, and read through, all of this material before finding the original source for Chambersâ claim. Unable to devote so much time to this one research project, when Iâm already juggling dozens of others, I chose to spend several days on it instead, before I traded in the pedant for the rhetor, and made an educated guess about which Bartholin â Caspar the Elder, or Thomas, or Rasmus, or Caspar the Younger â had commented on the number of Danish druggists at some point during the 17th century.
In the end, I settled on Thomas, based on my interpretation of the variety of Bartholin citations elsewhere in Chambersâ two-volume Cyclopaedia. But I could well be proven wrong in this hasty identification, which is a chance I would not take here at She-philosopher.com, where accuracy is paramount, and the historical detail rules. That doesnât mean there are no mistakes at She-philosopher.com; alas, there are probably plenty, as with much historical research of this nature. But I never knowingly finesse the truth here, for purposes of kairos or expediency.
So, as you read through the content on display at the new She-philosopher.com, bear in mind that even a seemingly simple, tweet-length phrase â â... the eminent Danish physician and natural philosopher, Thomas Bartholin (1616â1680), had complained ...â â can take many months to fact-check properly.
The new She-philosopher.com is a concatenation of many such phrases ... which is how months turn into years, and Iâm still working on the beta-release version of a transitional website....
A note about donating to She-philosopher.com: There is a new TLS/SSL-secured Support Us page for this purpose (see the navigation bar at top & bottom of this page), which is properly secured for commercial transactions using the HTTPS secure protocol. As you make use of She-philosopher.com and its unique resources, please consider contributing to this websiteâs maintenance & further development with a small financial donation. She-philosopher.com is visitor-supported, and independent of large foundation money and corporate/state sponsorship.
Keeping high-quality, independent scholarship on the Web is a worthy, but underfunded, cause. So if you do decide to make She-philosopher.com one of your philanthropic priorities â yes, philanthropy knows no income bracket (it is the act of donating, rather than the amount given, that makes you a philanthropist ;-) â you have my heartfelt thanks!
Anyone wanting to use, link to, reference, or cite content at the new and improved She-philosopher.com should read the âConditions of Useâ page and/or contact the website editor for permission and/or instructions.
^ Title-page ornament from the 1753 Supplement to Ephraim Chambersâ Cyclopaedia, by George Lewis Scott, et al.
The design is an 18th-century twist on the Hermathena of Antiquity, a statue juxtaposing the sibling gods, Hermes and Athena. Traditional iconography has the statues of Mercury and Minerva raised on square pedestals and joined as one, the resulting hybrid deity serving as a symbol for the Ciceronian union of wisdom and eloquence (Wisdom restrains Eloquence, and Eloquence tempers Wisdom).
A Hermathena was chosen by Cicero (106â43 BCE) to ornament his lecture hall, and has been a traditional symbol of academies and scholarship ever since. For example, the Bolognese academic, Achille Bocchi (1488-1562), also used a Hermathena as the device (impresa) for his own school. His Hermes and Athena each had a columnlike base and upper torso on the corner of the façade for the Palazzo Bocchi; the two stone gods linked arms, and between them Eros reined the mouth of a lionâs head. (E. S. Watson, Achille Bocchi and the Emblem Book as Symbolic Form, 76)
I have been working on â âIâ being Deborah Taylor-Pearce, founder, publisher & editor of She-philosopher.com, first launched in April 2004 before the advent of Google and other Big Search tools for the Web. In the beginning, visitors to She-philosopher.com came because of my posts to various listservs and Usenet newsgroups, or because I had invited them by passing out URLs, or because of word-of-mouth. In other words, they either knew me or knew of me before visiting.
Having been at this for so long now, I tend to forget that not everyone who will land on this page in 2017 (or later) knows my identity. Moreover, I have less of an online presence now that I am no longer active in discussion forums (other than an occasional post to GitHub or other tech-support hang-outs), having chosen not to make the move to such popular social networks as Facebook and Twitter.
In March 2017, I was told by a new visitor to this website that it âcomes across as a bit oddâ to alight on this home page and be addressed by an anonymous she-philosopher who never introduces herself. Longship Captain Fred Blonder is right about that, and this note is intended to correct that oddity. Thank you, Fred, for the constructive criticism! ::
another kairic moment â From the encompassing term, kairos.
The classical term, kairos, is of obscure origin and etymology, and difficult to define.
âIt is translated in English as âthe right time,â âdue season,â âoccasion,â âopportune,â âappropriate,â âsuitable,â âthe fitting,â âthe propitious moment,â âarising circumstances,â and âopportunity.ââ (Encyclopedia of Rhetoric, ed. Thomas O. Sloane, 2001, 413) ::
I settled on Thomas â Thomas Bartholin (1616â1680).
I have reason to think that Chambersâ source for the mid-17th-century complaint about the growing number of Danish druggists competing with physicians for market share, professional status, and perquisites, was Bartholinâs Cista medica Hafniensis, variis consiliis, curationibus, casibus rarioribus, vitis medicorum Hafniensium ... Accedit ... Domus anatomica brevissime descripta (Copenhagen: Matthias Godicchenius, 1662), but I do not presently have the time or resources to verify this scholarly intuition. ::
one of six guiding principles — The preamble to The Constitution of the General Government (1789) lists 6 founding principles, and reads in full: “We, the people of the UNITED STATES, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common defence, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, DO ordain and establish this CONSTITUTION for the United States of AMERICA.” (as printed by William Kilty in 1799, “under the authority of the legislature” for the state of Maryland, with text “copied from [that] published during the year seventeen hundred and ninety-nine by order of the house of representatives”) ::
whose personhood is beyond dispute — Those who believe that âpersonhood begins at conceptionâ have been emboldened by the fall of Roe v. Wade to push for âpersonhoodâ laws, giving legal rights to unborn children.
While the legal fiction of fetal personhood does indeed date to the 17th century (at which time laws were passed protecting the fetusâs private property rights), supposing the fetus âin law to be born for many purposesâ â so that âIt is capable of having a legacy, or a surrender of a copyhold estate made to it. It may have a guardian assigned to it; and it is enabled to have an estate limited to itâs use, and to take afterwards by such limitation, as if it were then actually born.â (William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England, 4 vols., 3rd edn., 1768, 1.130) â is not the same thing as bestowing personhood upon it. Cf. Virginiaâs 1699 and 1705 statutes disenfranchising women, Roman Catholic recusants, and âinfantsâ (minors under 21 years of age).
Indeed, through at least the 18th century, the fetus â corporeal, but irrational and not yet individuated â was by definition not a âperson,â which âWord came at length to import the Mind, as being a Thing of the greatest Regard and Dignity among human Mattersâ: âPERSON, an individual Substance, of a rational or intelligent Nature.â (Ephraim Chambers, Cyclopaedia, 2 vols., 1728, s.v. Person, 2.793).
âPerson is definâd an individual, reasonable, or intellectual Substance; or, an intellectual and incommunicable Substance.â (E. Chambers, Cyclopaedia, 2 vols., 1728, s.v. Trinity, 2.251) ::
RetroSearch is an open source project built by @garambo | Open a GitHub Issue
Search and Browse the WWW like it's 1997 | Search results from DuckDuckGo
HTML:
3.2
| Encoding:
UTF-8
| Version:
0.7.4